When Charles Dickens wrote, "It was the best of times,
it was the worst of times" to begin "A Tale of Two Cities," he
compared the years of the French Revolution to his own "present
period.”
Both were wracked with inequality. But he couldn't
have known that 75 years later inequality would cause the Great Depression. Or
that 75 years after that, in our own present period, extreme inequality would
return for a fourth time, to impact a much greater number of people.
He probably didn't know that the cycles of history seem to
drag the developed world into desperate times about every 75 years, and then
seek relief through war or revolution.
It's that time again.
Three cycles (225 years) ago, in the years before the French Revolution,
inequality was at one of its highest points ever. While it's estimated that the
top 10 percent of the population took almost half the income, as they do today,
the Gini Coefficient was between .52 and .59, higher than the current U.S.
figure of .47.
The French Revolution began a surge toward equality that
lasted well into the 19th century.
Two cycles ago, in Dickens' day of the 1860s, European inequality was again at
a nearly intolerable level. It took the second industrial revolution and the
U.S. Civil War to start correcting the economic injustices.
One cycle ago was the Great Depression. The New Deal, World War 2, and the
laborious process of war recovery put an end to this third period of extreme
inequality.
Now, nearly 75 years after we started World War 2 production, we again feel the
agony of a wealth gap expanding, like grotesquely stretched muscle, to
intolerable limits. If history repeats itself, we will be part of another
revolution of long-subjugated people.
Indeed, it has already begun, in Europe
and Canada and with the Occupy Movement.
The face of plutocracy has changed, but not the consequences. Just before the
French Revolution, Paris and London were dismal places for the masses, with
islands of unimaginable splendor for aristocrats, who, like the
multi-millionaires of today, found it hard to relate to the commoners.
Dickens portrayed it well. Exclaimed the Marquis St.
Evremonde to a gathering crowd: "It is extraordinary to me that you people
cannot take care of yourselves and your children. One or the other of you is
forever in the way. How do I know what injury you have done to my horses?"
This he said after his carriage had struck and killed a young child.
Today the two cities could be Los Angeles and Chicago, both among the ten most
unequal metropolitan areas in the United States. Instead of lords and noblemen,
we have CEOs and hedge fund managers. The economic injustices are fashioned in
more civilized ways. Insidious ways.
Los Angeles is the biggest city in a state with a $9-16 billion budget deficit.
It is facing severe cuts in education, health care, social services, and the
court system. College tuition increased 50 percent in two years. Public schools
are down to one counselor for every 800 students.
But California's deficit wouldn't exist if corporations had paid their state
taxes. Apple is a prime example of nonpayment. While the company's 10 percent
federal tax rate has been widely publicized, its 2 percent state payment
(rather than the required 9 percent) is less well known.
For state avoidance purposes, they claim residency in
Nevada. And despite conducting most of its research and development in the
United States, they channel much of their sales through Luxembourg and Ireland
and the Caribbean.
What about Chicago? It has the highest sales tax in the country. Illinois cut
2012 education spending by a greater percentage than any other state. The state
tax rate was just increased by 66 percent. Property taxes went up by about $300
per homeowner. Illinois was recently named one of the ten "Most Regressive
State Tax Systems," with the third-highest "Taxes on the Poor."
Yet if just 20 large Illinois companies had paid state taxes at the required
statutory rate over the past three years, an additional $7.5 billion would have
come back to the state, or about half of the state's current deficit.
Just as Los Angeles loses out to technology, Chicago is victimized by finance.
The Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME), with billions of untaxed contracts worth
well over a quadrillion dollars, and whose profit margin over the past three
years is higher than any of the top 100 companies in the nation, demanded and
received an $85 million per year tax break.
"A man grown grey in treachery...who once when it was objected, to some
finance scheme of his, 'What will the people do?' - made answer, in the fire of
discussion, 'The people may eat grass.'" -- Thomas Carlyle, "The
French Revolution," the main source for Dickens' novel.
In our 'civilized' times people aren't being run down by noblemen or forced to
eat grass. The aristocracy has learned a lot about suppressing crowds in 225
years. But they need to fear the growing revolution.
They need to fear, as
Dickens put it, "the remorseless sea of turbulently swaying shapes, voices
of vengeance, and faces hardened in the furnaces of suffering until the touch
of pity could make no mark on them." (X)
Paul
Buchheit is a contributor to Nation
of Change magazine, where this article originally appeared.